Manly’s hooking stocks have taken a major hit with utility Lachlan Croker reportedly set to miss the opening three rounds after suffering a hamstring injury.
Wide World of Sports reports the 24-year-old picked up the injury during training this week.
The club has not yet confirmed Croker’s injury, but he was not named to play Sunday’s trial match against the Wests Tigers.
It’s important to note that halves duo Daly Cherry-Evans and Kieran Foran were also not named in the squad — suggesting coach Des Hasler is resting his key men. However, Foxsports.com.au understands Croker as well as fellow utility Cade Cust both had hamstring concerns earlier this month.
Round 1
Watch Live & On-Demand coverage of NRL pre-season trial matches on Kayo. New to Kayo? Get your 14-day free trial now & start streaming instantly >
It’s a worrying sign for the Sea Eagles given Croker was expected to get first shot at the No.9 jersey.
Hasler is relying on the duo to share the hooking role while Manase Fainu is sidelined under the NRL’s no-fault stand down police. He is due to face court in July over an alleged stabbing.
Personally, this is also huge blow for Croker who played every game last season for the first time in his NRL career.
Croker’s injury comes just days after superstar fullback Tom Trbojevic was ruled out of the first three rounds after suffering a grade two tear of his hamstring. The 24-year-old claims it happened when he slipped in the shower however footage emerged of him racing a fan on a night out in Manly last weekend.
Arrow backs Rabbitohs to be contenders
3:05
FULL CASUALTY WARD
BRONCOS
Corey Oates (hand) – trials
Herbie Farnworth (chest) – Round 1
Tom Flegler (shoulder) – Round 1
Anthony Milford (broken hand) – Round 1-2
Payne Haas (suspended) – Round 4
Dale Copley (throat) – indefinite
Kotoni Staggs (knee) – mid-season
RAIDERS
Ryan James (knee) – trials
Bailey Simonsson (leg) – trials
Josh Hodgson (knee) – Round 1
Ryan Sutton (knee) – Round 1
Corey Horsburgh (foot) – Round 1
Emre Guler (ankle) – Round 1
Curtis Scott (leg) – Round 1
Jarrod Croker (shoulder) – Round 3-4
BULLDOGS
Jeremy Marshall-King (foot) – Round 1-3
Adam Elliott (shoulder) – trials
Joe Stimson (shoulder) – trials
Dylan Napa (knee) – trials
Jake Averillo (elbow) – Round 1
Raymond Faitala-Mariner (ankle) – Round 1
Luke Thompson (suspended) – Round 5
Jayden Okunbor (knee) – mid-late season
Christian Crichton (knee) – season
Get all the latest NRL news, highlights and analysis delivered straight to your inbox with Fox Sports Sportmail. Sign up now!!!
SHARKS
Blayke Brailey (ankle) – trials
Matt Moylan (hamstring) – trials
Josh Dugan (neck) – trials/Round 1
Wade Graham (perforated eardrum) – Round 1
Royce Hunt (knee) – Round 1-2
Siosifa Talakai (shoulder) – Round 1-3
Shaun Johnson (Achilles) – Round 5-8
Jack A Williams (throat) – indefinite
Bronson Xerri (stood down)
TITANS
David Fifita (thumb) – trials
Tino Fa’asuamaleaui (knee) – trials
AJ Brimson (foot) – trials
Jai Whitbread (ankle) – trials
Ash Taylor (hip/wrist) – trials
Sam McIntyre (foot) – trials
Kevin Proctor (hamstring) – Round 1
Fijian team issue heartfelt thanks
1:28
SEA EAGLES
Josh Aloiai (knee) – trials
Dylan Walker (foot) – trials
Kieran Foran (pectoral) – Round 1
Josh Schuster (ankle) – Round 1
Moses Suli (foot) – Round 1
Lachlan Croker (hamstring) – Round 4
Tom Trbojevic (hamstring) – Round 4
Jorge Taufua (Achilles) – April
Manase Fainu (stood down)
SUAALII WATCH: How you can see teen Chooks stars in action on Kayo
TRANSFER CENTRE: Panthers lock up star centre with contract extension
STORM
N/A
KNIGHTS
Jayden Brailey (knee) – trials
Connor Watson (Achilles) – trials
Mitchell Pearce (thumb) – trials/Round 1
Edrick Lee (foot) – Round 2-3
Kalyn Ponga (shoulder) – Round 1-4
Blake Green (knee) – Round 5-8
Jirah Momoisea (Achilles) – indefinite
Lachlan Fitzgibbon (shoulder) – indefinite
COWBOYS
Jordan McLean (hamstring) – trials
Michael Morgan (calf) – Round 1
Kyle Feldt (groin) – Round 1
Tom Gilbert (leg) – Round 2-4
Kane Bradley (shoulder) – Round 4
EELS
Blake Ferguson (knee) – Round 1
Maika Sivo (knee) – Round 1
Marata Niukore (suspended) – Round 2
Bryce Cartwright (jaw) – Round 2-4
Michael Oldfield (knee) – Round 4
Michael Jennings (stood down)
PANTHERS
Charlie Staines (hamstring) – trials
RABBITOHS
Cameron Murray (hamstring) – trials
Adam Reynolds (groin) – trials
Junior Tatola (ankle/knee) – trials
Jai Arrow (hamstring) – Round 1
Taane Milne (knee) – Round 1-4
Braidon Burns (knee) – Round 1-4
Brock Gardner (Achilles) – indefinite
DRAGONS
Jack Bird (knee) – trials
Billy Brittain (shoulder) – Round 1
Cameron McInnes (knee) – season
Jack de Belin (stood down)
Crichton signs extension with Panthers
0:30
ROOSTERS
Siosiua Taukeiaho (knee) – trials
Luke Keary (hamstring) — Round 1
Victor Radley (knee) – Round 1-2
Sam Verrills (knee) – Round 1-2
Billy Smith (shoulder) – mid-season
Boyd Cordner (concussion) – indefinite
WARRIORS
Ben Murdoch-Masila (pectoral) – trials
Leeson Ah Mau (pectoral) – trials
Jackson Frei (knee) – trials
Bunty Afoa (knee) – trials
Eliesa Katoa (eye-scoket) – Round 1
Karl Lawton (Achilles) – late season
TIGERS
Moses Mbye (hamstring) – Round 1
Adam Doueihi (suspended) – Round 2
James Roberts (pectoral) – trials
Zane Musgrove (suspended) – Round 3
Shawn Blore (wrist) – Round 6
Billy Walters (knee) – indefinite
Thanks for dropping by and seeing this post on League news called “NRL 2021: Lachlan Croker hamstring injury, hooker replacement, Manly Sea Eales, casualty ward, injuries, return dates”. This news article was brought to you by MyLocalPages as part of our Australian news services.
Mitchell Pearce and Lachlan Fitzgibbon will endure a tense reunion when the under-fire Newcastle Knights skipper returns to preseason training this week.
Pearce’s personal life and his standing at his NRL club is in tatters after he was caught sexting a Knights employee just days out from his wedding to Kristin Scott.
The wedding was cancelled and Pearce is desperately trying to repair his relationship. He’s also preparing to face the music at his footy club.
Teammate Lachlan Fitzgibbon is a close friend of the boyfriend of the club employee and was reportedly furious at Pearce’s actions.
It will all come to a head at training later this week, where Knights general manager of football Danny Buderus is hoping it can be addressed promptly for the sake of the upcoming season.
“There will be an address from Mitchell,” Buderus told reporters on Monday.
“It definitely needs to be addressed (immediately) when he comes back … otherwise it can fester among the group,” he added.
“Mitchell would like it that way. Anyone who walks into that group needs to understand what they’ve all gone through and the pressure the club has been under in the (past) 12 days.
“Something needs to be said and once it’s said we can all move on.”
Buderus praised Fitzgibbon for the way he was dealing with the situation. “He’s shown some really good leadership in and around it, understanding what he needs to move forward so we’re addressing all those areas among the group to ensure all parties are happy to get back out on to the football field.”
Pearce’s days of leading his teammates on to that field appear over though.
Buderus said coach Adam O’Brien was conducting a review of the club’s player leadership model and conceded stripping Pearce of the captaincy was an option.
“He likes to be captain, so if it was to go that way it would hurt,” Buderus said.
Buderus said Pearce’s main focus for now was his relationship with Scott.
“It’s difficult. You can only imagine how he’s going,” he said.
Buderus stressed Pearce was still wanted at the Knights but admitted the scandal could affect contract negotiations with the former NSW Blues representative.
Pearce’s current $1 million-a-season contract ends after the 2021 season. The Daily Telegraph reported that he was offered a two-year extension that halved his salary before this latest scandal.
“We’re still going through that (contract renegotiation) process. There’s (going to be) a lot of personal impact for Mitchell, professionally as well, but that’s a bridge we need to cross when we get to it.”
news, local-news, Goulburn, Taralga, Upper Lachlan Shire Council, water treatment plant, John Stafford, new dam, Colleen Worthy
The estimated $220,000 cost of replacing Taralga’s water treatment plant will be money well spent if it relieves residents of ‘stringent restrictions.’ That’s the view of Upper Lachlan Shire Mayor John Stafford who told a council meeting on Thursday that the community was “beside itself” and “outraged” over the water treatment plant’s recent destruction by fire and implementation of level three restrictions. Councillors voted unanimously to give general manager Colleen Worthy delegated authority to buy a replacement water filtration plant for the facility off Martyn Street. They also want the Department of Planning, Infrastructure and Environment to “confirm” the purchase. READ MORE: Taralga water plant purchase paves way to permanent solution Firefighters contain structure fire at Taralga Ignition point unknown at Taralga blaze, firefighters say Taralga water restrictions tighten after structure fire A near two-week search has identified a plant from South Australia, estimated to cost $220,000. It’s not yet known if the state government will assist but the GM says the council is regularly meeting with departments on this point and financial assistance with water carting from Crookwell in the interim. Thursday’s meeting sparked questions from councillors, including one from Cr James Wheelwright on whether the plant was “cheap,” would provide for the future and if DPIE would help if it didn’t do the job. Mrs Worthy replied that any suggestion it was of low quality was “wrong.” She said the plant had a five to 10-year life and could be sold if the council built a larger dam in future and needed a bigger filtration system. “This is a plant for this time,” she said. The council wants it operating by February to save paying over $100,000/month in water cartage costs. Under questioning from Cr Brian McCormack about the blaze and why it happened, Mrs Worthy said fire authorities, police and the insurance company had all agreed it was an electrical fault. ALSO READ: Man sentenced to prison for connection to alleged Marulan cannabis cultivation Asked by The Post about the maintenance regime, Mrs Worthy said the council employed “a highly experienced and a highly skilled group of plant operators that monitored and maintained all of its water treatment plant assets expertly and diligently.” “The water treatment plant at Taralga was no exception, being cared for by staff with decades of experience in plant operations and maintenance,” she said. After the meeting, Cr Stafford said councillors naturally had questions after only receiving the council report that morning but were largely assured it was the right course of action. “There is no question it will meet our needs,” he told The Post. “…It’s not an extraordinary amount of money and in the event we need something further in the future, we’ll look at that. “The important thing is to get water to the people and get them off level three restrictions.” The mayor said the council was “going full bore” to meet community needs and praised management and staff for identifying the plant so soon after the December 8 fire. He acknowledged “a degree of frustration” by residents about being on tight restrictions amid one of the best agricultural seasons. Taralga was on the same limits last summer amid drought. ALSO READ: Throwback Thursday: Kids of Goulburn, December 1995 | Photos “Some people, unreasonably so, want an instant fix, which is not possible but at the same time we, as a council, have to apply ourselves to do this as quickly as we can,” he said. Mrs Worthy hoped the council would only foot a small portion of the bill once state assistance was known and an insurance claim assessed. Meantime, talks are underway with three landowners about possible acquisition for a new dam, replacing the current one which has leaks. Cr Stafford said the council was exploring a 50 megalitre storage near to the existing 20Ml dam, to cater for the growing village into the future. We care about what you think. Have your say in the form below and if you love local news don’t forget to subscribe.
The estimated $220,000 cost of replacing Taralga’s water treatment plant will be money well spent if it relieves residents of ‘stringent restrictions.’
That’s the view of Upper Lachlan Shire Mayor John Stafford who told a council meeting on Thursday that the community was “beside itself” and “outraged” over the water treatment plant’s recent destruction by fire and implementation of level three restrictions.
Councillors voted unanimously to give general manager Colleen Worthy delegated authority to buy a replacement water filtration plant for the facility off Martyn Street. They also want the Department of Planning, Infrastructure and Environment to “confirm” the purchase.
A near two-week search has identified a plant from South Australia, estimated to cost $220,000. It’s not yet known if the state government will assist but the GM says the council is regularly meeting with departments on this point and financial assistance with water carting from Crookwell in the interim.
Thursday’s meeting sparked questions from councillors, including one from Cr James Wheelwright on whether the plant was “cheap,” would provide for the future and if DPIE would help if it didn’t do the job.
Mrs Worthy replied that any suggestion it was of low quality was “wrong.” She said the plant had a five to 10-year life and could be sold if the council built a larger dam in future and needed a bigger filtration system.
“This is a plant for this time,” she said.
The council wants it operating by February to save paying over $100,000/month in water cartage costs.
Under questioning from Cr Brian McCormack about the blaze and why it happened, Mrs Worthy said fire authorities, police and the insurance company had all agreed it was an electrical fault.
Asked by The Post about the maintenance regime, Mrs Worthy said the council employed “a highly experienced and a highly skilled group of plant operators that monitored and maintained all of its water treatment plant assets expertly and diligently.”
“The water treatment plant at Taralga was no exception, being cared for by staff with decades of experience in plant operations and maintenance,” she said.
Upper Lachlan Shire Mayor John Stafford says he’s confident the new water filtration plant for Taralga will do the job. Photo supplied.
After the meeting, Cr Stafford said councillors naturally had questions after only receiving the council report that morning but were largely assured it was the right course of action.
“There is no question it will meet our needs,” he told The Post.
“…It’s not an extraordinary amount of money and in the event we need something further in the future, we’ll look at that.
“The important thing is to get water to the people and get them off level three restrictions.”
The mayor said the council was “going full bore” to meet community needs and praised management and staff for identifying the plant so soon after the December 8 fire.
He acknowledged “a degree of frustration” by residents about being on tight restrictions amid one of the best agricultural seasons. Taralga was on the same limits last summer amid drought.
“Some people, unreasonably so, want an instant fix, which is not possible but at the same time we, as a council, have to apply ourselves to do this as quickly as we can,” he said.
Mrs Worthy hoped the council would only foot a small portion of the bill once state assistance was known and an insurance claim assessed.
Meantime, talks are underway with three landowners about possible acquisition for a new dam, replacing the current one which has leaks.
Cr Stafford said the council was exploring a 50 megalitre storage near to the existing 20Ml dam, to cater for the growing village into the future.
We care about what you think. Have your say in the form below and if you love local news don’t forget to subscribe.
The array of trade and free agency moves last month ensured several teams will go through dramatic makeovers when assembling their 2021 best 22s.
But with many recent AFL draftees every chance to push into early senior selection contention, several clubs now have a few more internal headaches.
Foxfooty.com.au has updated how your club’s best 22 could look like next season.
Get all the latest AFL news, highlights and analysis delivered straight to your inbox with Fox Sports Sportmail. Sign up now!
Grand Final
ADELAIDE CROWS
B: Luke Brown, Daniel Talia, Tom Doedee
HB: Andrew McPherson, Fisher McAsey, Brodie Smith
C: Will Hamill, Rory Sloane, Wayne Milera
HF:Jackson Hately, Darcy Fogarty, Tom Lynch
F: Shane McAdam, Elliot Himmelberg, James Rowe
FOLL: Reilly O’Brien, Matt Crouch, Rory Laird
I/C: Lachie Sholl, Ben Keays, Jake Kelly, Taylor Walker
In: Jackson Hately, Mitch Hinge, Riley Thilthorpe, Luke Pedlar, Brayden Cook, Sam Berry, James Rowe
Out: Bryce Gibbs, Riley Knight, Patrick Wilson, Ayce Taylor, Rory Atkins, Brad Crouch, Kyle Hartigan, Jordan Gallucci, Myles Poholke, Ben Crocker
We say: Jackson Hately joined the Crows via the pre-season draft, after they refused to pay more than Pick 40 for the 2018 first-round pick from GWS. He wants more time as an inside midfielder but will he have to rotate forward early on? The draftee most likely to come into the best 22 straight away is James Rowe — a mature-age recruit coming off a 38-goal season in the SANFL this year and could bring some ready-made experience into the side. We’ve left Chayce Jones out of the side for the moment after his patchy 2020 campaign, but a strong pre-season should see him fight his way into best 22 for Round 1.
Draftee’s dad tears up on air
1:54
BRISBANE LIONS
B: Callum Ah Chee, Harris Andrews, Grant Birchall
HB: Daniel Rich, Darcy Gardiner, Brandon Starcevich
C: Hugh McCluggage, Lachie Neale, Mitch Robinson
HF: Cam Rayner, Joe Daniher, Dayne Zorko
F: Charlie Cameron, Eric Hipwood, Daniel McStay
FOLL: Oscar McInerney, Jarryd Lyons, Jarrod Berry
I/C: Lincoln McCarthy, Zac Bailey, Nakia Cockatoo, Ryan Lester
In: Joe Daniher, Nakia Cockatoo, Blake Coleman, Harry Sharp, Henry Smith
Out: Allen Christensen, Matt Eagles, Corey Lyons, Jacob Allison, Sam Skinner, Toby Wooller, Stefan Martin, Alex Witherden
We say: Blake Coleman is the only draftee who could potentially sneak into the best 22, but it’d still be a shock if he was picked just yet. The back six remains a tough task to select. We’ve selected two talls in Darcy Gardiner and Harris Andrews, but they could opt for a third in Jack Payne. But if Marcus Adams is fit – he’s had a horror run with injury while at the club – he might start ahead of Payne. Despite his new rookie contract and a slight dip in form towards the back-end of the season, we’ve kept Grant Birchall in the side — his attacking mindset played a huge role in brisbane’s improved ball movement in 2020 — meaning Noah Answerth, and Keidean Coleman miss out. Joe Daniher definitely plays from Round 1 if fit and Nakia Cockatoo probably should, pushing preliminary final team member Cam Ellis-Yolmen out. Daniher will assist Oscar McInerney in the ruck.
CARLTON
B: Caleb Marchbank, Liam Jones, Lachie Plowman
HB:Adam Saad, Jacob Weitering, Sam Docherty
C: Sam Petrevski-Seton, Sam Walsh, Marc Murphy
HF: Jack Martin, Charlie Curnow, Zac Fisher
F: Eddie Betts, Harry McKay, Michael Gibbons
FOLL: Tom De Koning, Patrick Cripps, Zac Williams
I/C: Will Setterfield, Ed Curnow, Levi Casboult, Jack Newnes
In: Zac Williams, Adam Saad, Lachie Fogarty, Corey Durdin, Jack Carroll, Luke Parks
Out: Hugh Goddard, Matthew Kreuzer, Darcy Lang, Finbar O’Dwyer, Ben Silvagni, Kade Simpson
We say: Perhaps trickiest part of selecting the Blues’ best 22 is around the array of small forward options. Eddie Betts probably starts in the team early in the season, but trade acquisition Lachie Fogarty or even recent draftee Corey Durdin would be just as capable of holding down a spot. Adam Saad slots straight in on a half-back and we’ve thrown Zac Williams straight in the guts. If Charlie Curnow is fit for Round 1, he plays — but that’s no sure thing. If he’s unavailable, Mitch McGovern — who we’ve left out — should replace him. Jack Carroll slid down the draft order and was dubbed “the steal of the draft” by Mick Ablett, but he’ll have to work his way into the side. Jack Newnes’ spot looks to be the one he’d take if he got a berth.
AFL new boys don colours
1:45
COLLINGWOOD
B: Brayden Maynard, Jordan Roughead, Jeremy Howe
HB: Jack Crisp, Darcy Moore, Isaac Quaynor
C: Josh Daicos, Scott Pendlebury, Chris Mayne
HF: Callum Brown, Brody Mihocek, Will Hoskin-Elliott
F: Jordan De Goey, Mason Cox, Jamie Elliott
FOLL: Brodie Grundy, Taylor Adams, Steele Sidebottom
I/C: John Noble, Will Kelly, Tyler Brown, Brayden Sier
In: Oliver Henry, Finlay Macrae, Reef McInnes, Caleb Poulter, Liam McMahon, Beau McCreery, Jack Ginnivan, Isaac Chugg
Out: Adam Treloar, Jaidyn Stephenson, Tom Phillips, Atu Bosenavulagi, Ben Reid
We say: The Magpies’ midfield now doesn’t bat as deep as past seasons. The club is hopeful the likes of Callum Brown, Tyler Brown and Brayden Sier can improve their outputs with the extra exposure they’ll receive next year. The draftees in the mix for a Round 1 spot would be midfielder Finlay Macrae and NGA recruit Reef McInnes, who were two of the best on-ball prospects of the 2020 draft class. With strong pre-seasons, they could easily push out any of the Brown brothers or Sier or John Noble. Pressure forward draftee Beau McCreery would be eyeing off Josh Thomas’ spot if he has a sluggish start to the season. Will Kelly is in — and he should be playing lots of senior footy in 2021.
ESSENDON
B: Mason Redman, Brandon Zerk-Thatcher, Patrick Ambrose
HB: Jordan Ridley, Michael Hurley, Nick Hind
C: Zach Merrett, Dyson Heppell, Andrew McGrath
HF: Jake Stringer, Peter Wright, Will Snelling
F: David Zaharakis, James Stewart, Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti
In: Peter Wright, Jye Caldwell, Nick Hind, Nikolas Cox, Archie Perkins, Zach Reid, Josh Eyre, Cody Brand
Out: Joe Daniher, Adam Saad, Orazio Fantasia, Conor McKenna, Tom Bellchambers, Shaun McKernan, Mitch Hibberd, Kobe Mutch, Josh Begley, Noah Gown
We say: That Bombers backline looks a little different. No Cale Hooker — 32-year-old struggled in defence towards the back-end of the year, but he could replace James Stewart up forward — but Brandon Zerk-Thatcher holds down full-back, with Nick Hind bringing extra speed off half-back to help fill the hole left by Adam Saad. The wildcard could be Nik Cox — one of the more unique prospects at 200cm who has great aerobic capacity, best non-preferred kick of all 2020 draftees and versatility to play almost anywhere on the ground — who has already declared he has his eyes on Round 1, 2021. The Bombers will be hoping midfield acquisition Jye Caldwell will have a break out year with greater opportunity, while they need the best out of Peter Wright, with the former Sun likely to be a key target close to goal after Joe Daniher departed.
Could Nik Cox surge into the Bombers’ best 22? Picture: Dylan BurnsSource: Getty Images
FREMANTLE
B: Luke Ryan, Joel Hamling, Brennan Cox
HB: Hayden Young, Alex Pearce, Nathan Wilson
C: Blake Acres, Caleb Serong, Darcy Tucker
HF: Sam Sturt, Matt Taberner, Michael Walters
F: Lachlan Shultz, Rory Lobb, Nat Fyfe
FOLL: Sean Darcy, Andrew Brayshaw, Adam Cerra
I/C: Reece Conca, David Mundy, James Aish, Ethan Hughes
Out: Isiah Butters, Jason Carter, Hugh Dixon, Jesse Hogan, Brandon Matera, Cam McCarthy, Tom North, Dillon O’Reilly, Jarvis Pina
We say: There’s now a massive selection squeeze on in Fremantle’s backline. The Docker have some serious talent to return from injury, with Alex Pearce and Joel Hamling arguably their two best key defenders. They’ll likely play a third tall — and despite Griffin Logue’s form pre-injury in 2020, it’s hard to ignore Brennan Cox’s outstanding season. Best and fairest winner Luke Ryan is the gun interceptor, while Nathan Wilson and Hayden Young provide ample drive off half-back. It’s a great mix. But it means the likes of Logue and top draftee Heath Chapman — who has the potential to play Round 1 — miss out. Also, could Nat Fyfe become a forward-mid? With David Mundy sticking around for one more year and Adam Cerra, Andrew Brayshaw and Caleb Serong only getting better, there’s arguably enough midfield depth to afford Fyfe to move – plus the forward line needs it. The other Round 1 bolter could be midfield draftee Nathan O’Driscoll, who had an excellent 2020 campaign that saw him play five WAFL league games.
GEELONG CATS
B: Jack Henry, Lachie Henderson, Jake Kolodjashnij
HB: Mark O’Connor, Mark Blicavs, Tom Stewart
C: Mitch Duncan, Joel Selwood, Sam Menegola
HF: Luke Dahlhaus, Jeremy Cameron, Shaun Higgins
F: Gryan Miers, Tom Hawkins, Sam Simpson
FOLL: Rhys Stanley, Patrick Dangerfield, Cam Guthrie
I/C: Zach Tuohy, Jed Bews, Brandan Parfitt, Isaac Smith
In: Jeremy Cameron, Isaac Smith, Shaun Higgins, Max Holmes, Shannon Neale, Nick Stevens
Out: Gary Ablett, Nakia Cockatoo, Lachie Fogarty, Jacob Kennerley, James Parsons, Blake Schlensog, Harry Taylor
We say: Given the caliber of this Cats side, it’s very difficult to see any of their draftees coming into the squad just yet. But the Cats’ three major trade inclusions all deserve a spot in the 22. Jeremy Cameron gives Tom Hawkins a partner in crime and allows Patrick Dangerfield to spend more time in the midfield, while Shaun Higgins replaces Gary Ablett. Meanwhile Isaac Smith might not be a starting wingman with guns Mitch Duncan and Sam Menegola in the side but he surely plays. They didn’t actually find a Harry Taylor replacement, though there are high hopes for 2019 draftee Sam De Koning. Round 1 might be too early for a like-for-like swap, so we’ve gone with Lachie Henderson and Mark Blicavs, though Chris Scott obviously loves using Blicavs around the ground. Esava Ratugolea stayed to fight for his spot, but the Cats are already pretty tall. Jordan Clark did the same thing but we have him and Gary Rohan as very unlucky to miss.
Geelong unveil new star trio
2:47
GOLD COAST SUNS
B: Connor Budarick, Sam Collins, Charlie Ballard
HB: Jack Bowes, Jack Lukosius, Oleg Markov
C: Brandon Ellis, Touk Miller, Lachie Weller
HF: Hugh Greenwood, Ben King, Ben Ainsworth
F: Izak Rankine, Sam Day, Alex Sexton
FOLL: Jarrod Witts, David Swallow, Matt Rowell
I/C: Noah Anderson, Rory Atkins, Elijah Hollands, Alex Davies
In: Rory Atkins, Oleg Markov, Elijah Hollands, Jacob Townsend, Jordan Murdoch, Aiden Fyfe, Rhys Nicholls, Alex Davies, Joel Jeffrey
Out: Pearce Hanley, Anthony Miles, George Horlin-Smith, Corey Ellis, Josh Schoenfeld, Mitch Riordan, Sam Fletcher, Jesse Joyce, Jacob Dawson, Jacob Heron, Peter Wright
We say: The Suns have assembled a strong list full of youngsters and will add some experience with Rory Atkins and Oleg Markov staking claims for best 22 spots. Matt Rowell and Noah Anderson will again take a step forward with another pre-season, while the club will welcome Alex Davies and Joel Jeffrey to the club as automatic selections via the club’s catchment zone. Davies is ready to go and should be right in the Round 1 mix. Elijah Hollands could well have been Pick 1 in the draft this year before tearing his ACL. He could be given a run to open the season, but he’s in no rush to get up for Round 1. We’ve put Hollands in at the expense of a very unlucky Wil Powell.
GWS GIANTS
B: Sam Taylor, Phil Davis, Adam Kennedy
HB: Lachie Whitfield, Nick Haynes, Lachie Ash
C: Josh Kelly, Jacob Hopper, Harry Perryman
HF: Toby Greene, Jake Riccardi, Matt de Boer
F: Jeremy Finlayson, Jesse Hogan, Brent Daniels
FOLL:Braydon Preuss, Stephen Coniglio, Tim Taranto
I/C:Jacob Wehr, Tom Green, Callan Ward, Daniel Lloyd
In: Jesse Hogan, Braydon Preuss, Tanner Bruhn, Conor Stone, Ryan Angwin, Cameron Fleeton, Jacob Wehr
Out: Sam Jacobs, Heath Shaw, Tom Sheridan, Zac Williams, Aidan Corr, Zac Langdon, Jeremy Cameron, Jye Caldwell
We say: The Giants on paper still have a reasonable core group with Coniglio, Taranto and Kelly in the midfield group. It’s hard to say any team can ‘afford’ to lose players like Zac Williams and Jeremy Cameron, but they’ve certainly got depth in their old roles. Braydon Preuss will slot straight in as a ruck, while a big pre-season from Jesse Hogan should see him push for selection in the 22, with Harry Himmelberg perhaps the forward that makes way considering Jeremy Finlayson can also help in the ruck. Expect more from youngsters Lachie Ash and Jake Riccardi, while a stronger defensive unit should be complemented by Lachie Whitfield. The bolter could be mature-age recruit Jacob Wehr — a classy distributor off half-back with a beautiful kick that was a mainstay of the Eagles’ SANFL premiership team in 2020. He could be fighting for a spot with Isaac Cumming.
New Giant’s bizarre reaction
0:42
HAWTHORN
B: Sam Frost, Kyle Hartigan, Blake Hardwick
HB: Jack Scrimshaw, Denver Grainger-Barras, Jarman Impey
C:Tom Phillips, Tom Mitchell, Tom Scully
HF: Chad Wingard, Jack Gunston, Shaun Burgoyne
F: Tim O’Brien, Jon Patton, Luke Breust
FOLL: Ben McEvoy, James Worpel, Jaeger O’Meara
I/C: Liam Shiels, Will Day, Jon Ceglar, James Cousins
In: Kyle Hartigan, Tom Phillips, Denver Grainger-Barras, Seamus Mitchell, Connor Downie, Tyler Brockman, Jack Saunders
Out: Ben Stratton, Paul Puopolo, Conor Glass, Ricky Henderson, Darren Minchington, Jackson Ross, Will Golds, James Frawley, Isaac Smith
We say: The Hawks used an AFL-high 40 players this past season – tied with Collingwood (due to injuries) and the Bulldogs (due to Luke Beveridge doing Luke Beveridge things) – so the youth movement is finally getting underway. Five stalwarts are gone (Ben Stratton, Paul Puopolo, Ricky Henderson, James Frawley and Isaac Smith) and James Sicily likely won’t play much if at all in 2021, so it’s whether Alastair Clarkson goes full rebuild and plays the kids, or opts for the remaining veterans. We’re backing their top draftee Denver Grainger-Barras — a Dylan Grimes clone with great closing speed, awesome intercept ability and the versatility to match up on both small and tall forwards — to play straight away. Their two recruits slot straight in, Hartigan as a much-needed defender and Phillips back in his natural wing spot replacing Henderson to create what we’re calling the Tom line. We have McEvoy in the ruck and Ceglar on the bench, meaning Mitch Lewis misses out.
MELBOURNE
B: Michael Hibberd, Steven May, Adam Tomlinson
HB: Trent Rivers, Jake Lever, Christian Salem
C: James Harmes, Angus Brayshaw, Ed Langdon
HF: Bayley Fritsch, Sam Weideman, Jake Melksham
F: Kysaiah Pickett, Ben Brown, Jayden Hunt
FOLL: Max Gawn, Clayton Oliver, Christian Petracca
I/C: Jack Viney, Luke Jackson, Aaron vandenBerg, Bailey Laurie
In: Ben Brown, Jack Bowey, Bailey Laurie, Fraser Rosman
We say: Melbourne’s major change for 2021 is in the forward line, where Ben Brown partners with Sam Weideman and Luke Jackson as the three talls, with Jackson supporting Gawn in the ruck. It means there’s no room for Tom McDonald unless he switches into defence – though we’re not sure who he pushes out there – or someone gets hurt. Of the draftees, small pressure forward Bailey Laurie could come into the side straight away as he fills a chasm the Dees have had for a while. Laurie could be fighting it out with Charlie Spargo, Oskar Baker and Jay Lockhart for a spot. Adam Tomlinson looked better in defence when he switched there later in 2020.
Will Phillips will wear Brent Harvey’s old No. 29 at the Kangaroos. Picture: Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)Source: Getty Images
NORTH MELBOURNE
B: Josh Walker, Ben McKay, Aidan Corr
HB: Luke McDonald, Robbie Tarrant, Shaun Atley
C: Jared Polec, Ben Cunnington, Jed Anderson
HF: Luke Davies-Uniacke, Cam Zurhaar, Tarryn Thomas
F:Jaidyn Stephenson, Nick Larkey, Jack Ziebell
FOLL: Todd Goldstein, Trent Dumont, Jy Simpkin
I/C:Lachie Young, Will Phillips, Bailey Scott, Curtis Taylor
In: Aidan Corr, Lachie Young, Jaidyn Stephenson, Atu Bosenavulagi, Will Phillips, Tom Powell, Charlie Lazzaro, Phoenix Spicer, Eddie Ford, Patrick Walker, Connor Menadue
Out: Jamie Macmillan, Majak Daw, Jasper Pittard, Ben Jacobs, Paul Ahern, Mason Wood, Sam Durdin, Marley Williams, Joel Crocker, Lachie Hosie, Tom Murphy, Shaun Higgins, Ben Brown
We say: North picked up the best pure midfielder in the draft in Will Phillips — and he’ll be ready for, not only Round 1, but the entire season barring any unforeseen circumstances. Phillips will bring class, toughness and an ability to hit the scoreboard to the Roos. Like Matthew Rowell last year, Phillips could have a significant impact early, although probably not the same impact as Rowell. Aidan Corr slots straight into defence and Lachie Young is a contender to join him, while Jaidyn Stephenson steps into a pretty exciting young forward line. Polec is too good not to get a game in this side, even with his issues in 2020. Walker keeps his spot for now but in an ideal world younger guys like Tristan Xerri and Charlie Comben are pushing him out. Connor Menadue, Flynn Perez, Aiden Bonar and Jack Mahony are in the mix as well – it depends on how young new coach David Noble wants this side to be.
Out: Joe Atley, Wylie Buzza, Tobin Cox, Riley Grundy, Jack Watts, Brad Ebert, Cam Sutcliffe, Justin Westhoff, Jake Patmore
We say: We have recruits Aliir Aliir and Orazio Fantasia in the senior side, with Aliir being lured across to join a stellar defensive group, but Fantasia is no sure thing to start. The slightly controversial call is leaving out hybrid defender Ryan Burton for NGA recruit Lachlan Jones, who played ample SANFL league footy in 2020 and has an AFL ready-made frame. Jones is a strong rebounder and has the ability to play on both small and tall forwards, which will complement Aliir, Tom Clurey, Tom Jonas and Trent McKenzie well. We have Todd Marshall holding his spot in the forward line, but Mitch Georgiades is coming for it.
I/C: Jack Graham, Marlion Pickett, Liam Baker, Nathan Broad
In: Samson Ryan, Maurice Rioli
Out: Luke English, Fraser Turner, Oleg Markov, Jack Higgins
We say: Don’t expect too many changes to the reigning premiers’ best 22, especially considering no big name has elected to leave the club during the off-season. Oleg Markov and Jack Higgins both played throughout 2020, but missed out on the Grand Final, with the pair seeking opportunity at the Suns and Saints respectively.
ST KILDA
B: Callum Wilkie, Dougal Howard, Ben Paton
HB: Hunter Clark, Jake Carlisle, Nick Coffield,
C: Bradley Hill, Brad Crouch, Jack Billings
HF:Jack Higgins, Tim Membrey, Jade Gresham
F: Dan Butler, Max King, Jarryn Geary
FOLL: Rowan Marshall, Zak Jones, Jack Steele
I/C: Josh Battle, Paddy Ryder, Seb Ross, Dan Hannebery
In: Brad Crouch, Shaun McKernan, Jack Higgins, James Frawley, Matthew McLeod-Allison, Tom Highmore
Out: Nathan Brown, Doulton Langlands, Ryan Abbott, Jack Bell, Jack Mayo, Logan Austin, Matt Parker, Nick Hind
We say: This is a heck of a squad. The Saints added two walk-up starters during the trade period, with Jack Higgins to be a mid-forward and Brad Crouch to join the on-ball engine room (after missing the opening two rounds of the season through suspension, that is). Ben Long is clearly a coach favourite, but we’ve left him out of the side for now. Jarryn Geary did such a good job as a neutralising forward, especially on Caleb Daniel in the elimination final win that he probably spends more time there in 2021. And it’s hard to include Shaun McKernan considering the stellar combo of Rowan Marshall and Paddy Ryder, while James Frawley just misses out … for now.
Braeden Campbell of the Swans could play senior footy early. Picture: Jenny EvansSource: Getty Images
SYDNEY SWANS
B: Lewis Melican, Dane Rampe, Callum Mills
HB: Jordan Dawson, Tom McCartin, Jake Lloyd
C: Nick Blakey, Luke Parker, Ollie Florent
HF: Isaac Heeney, Lance Franklin, Will Hayward
F: Tom Papley, Logan McDonald, Callum Sinclair
FOLL:Tom Hickey, Josh Kennedy, James Rowbottom
I/C: Dylan Stephens, Harry Cunningham, Justin McInerney, Braeden Campbell
Out: Michael Knoll, Harry Reynolds, Brady Rowles, Ryley Stoddard, Jack Maibaum, Aliir Aliir
We say: There’s a genuine chance we could see all three of the Swans’ national draft recruits line up in the best 22, but we’ve gone for two at this stage. Key forward Logan McDonald was a standout in the WAFL league 2020 season, slotting 21 goals to finish fourth on the goalkicking ladder, while top Academy selection Braeden Campbell — a classy left-footer with ample zip — has the potential to make a big impact at AFL level early. Fellow Academy recruit Errol Gulden is also in the mix, but we’ve left him out at this stage. We’ve also left out George Hewett, who’s the most unlucky player to miss. Expect John Longmire to use Tom Hickey and Callum Sinclair in combination with the latter spending more time forward. They’ve got quite a few virtual recruits for 2021 thanks to their horror injury run this past season, most notably a certain Lance Franklin.
WEST COAST EAGLES
B:Alex Witherden, Tom Barrass, Brad Sheppard
HB: Shannon Hurn, Jeremy McGovern, Liam Duggan
C: Dom Sheed, Tim Kelly, Andrew Gaff
HF: Jamie Cripps, Jack Darling, Jake Waterman
F: Oscar Allen, Josh Kennedy, Liam Ryan
FOLL: Nic Naitanui, Elliot Yeo, Luke Shuey
I/C: Jack Petruccelle, Jackson Nelson, Jack Redden, Zac Langdon
In: Zac Langdon, Alex Witherden, Luke Edwards, Isiah Winder, Zane Trew
Out: Will Schofield, Nic Reid, Hamish Brayshaw, Francis Watson, Anthony Treacy, Mitch O’Neill
We say: The Eagles are pretty settled. Their two trade recruits, Zac Langdon and Alex Witherden, aren’t walk-up starters but you would assume the Eagles wouldn’t have given up their top draft picks for players they won’t heavily consider in the 22. Langdon will be battling guys like Brandon Ah Chee, Jarrod Cameron and Jamaine Jones for the small forward role. Witherden is ideally a long-term Shannon Hurn replacement, but is no sure thing to play right away ahead of Tom Cole and Jackson Nelson, plus Jarrod Brander is looking at switching into defence for more playing time.
#1 pick’s ‘unreal experience’
1:55
WESTERN BULLDOGS
B: Easton Wood, Alex Keath, Caleb Daniel
HB: Bailey Williams, Zaine Cordy, Hayden Crozier
C: Lachie Hunter, Jack Macrae, Adam Treloar
HF: Josh Dunkley, Aaron Naughton, Bailey Smith
F:Mitch Hannan, Jamarra Ugle-Hagan, Mitch Wallis
FOLL: Tim English, Marcus Bontempelli, Tom Liberatore
I/C:Stefan Martin, Jason Johannisen, Ed Richards, Josh Bruce
In: Mitch Hannan, Stefan Martin, Adam Treloar, Jamarra Ugle-Hagan, Dominic Bedendo, Lachlan McNeil
Out: Tory Dickson, Billy Gowers, Fergus Greene, Brad Lynch, Lachie Young
We say: What a tough team to pick. We’ve pulled the trigger and put No. 1 pick Jamarra Ugle-Hagan at full-forward. He was a standout as a bottom-ager at Under 18 level and he was clearly the best player of the 2020 draft class — he should be ready. But Josh Bruce also holds his spot, despite a difficult first year at the kennel. He gets a spot on the bench as has genuine versatility to play as a forward, defender or pinch-hit ruckman. We have all three trade period recruits in the best 22, but finding a spot for Adam Treloar isn’t easy. Both Stefan Martin and Tim English play, but whether one naturally assumes the No. 1 ruck mantle will be a fascinating storyline to follow. In defence, where the Dogs were torn apart via the air against St Kilda in their elimination final loss, it’s a toss-up between the maligned Ryan Gardner and Zaine Cordy.
South Australian apprentice Lachlan Neindorf is leaning towards extending his Victorian stint when his six-month loan to the Anthony and Sam Freedman stables expires in two weeks.
Superior opportunities are an enticing lure for Neindorf who initially joined the Freeman camp for a three-month term following the Adelaide autumn carnival.
As well as working out of Pinecliff, Neindorf has been encouraged by his support from leading stables such as Ben Hayes and Tom Dabernig.
“I have to make a decision in two weeks and I will probably stay,” Neindorf said.
Kayo is your ticket to the best sport streaming Live & On-Demand. New to Kayo? Get your 14-day free trial & start streaming instantly >
“I like it over here, race riding every day.
“I love working at Pinecliff, it is a nice set up and more laid back than track work at normal tracks. Anthony and Sam are really good.
“Anthony is a bit of a hard task master, a bit old school and he tries to get the best out of you. Robbie Scarlett rides trackwork and he has been an enormous help for me.
“He helps me out a lot and is always giving advice. I could not have asked for a better track work rider to help me out.”
Neindorf rode Cataracta from the Ciaron Maher and David Eustice stable, and Harpuna at Moonee Valley when they had their most recent starts and the pair will meet over 1200m at Morphettville on Saturday.
So which horse would the youngster ride in the BenchMark 64 race if he had to choose?
“Harpuna is a progressive horse which hasn’t really come into his own,” Neindorf said.
“He is still doing things wrong.
“At the Valley, and (Morphettville) Parks the start before, he struggled to get around the turn. When he straightens up he does rocket.
“I was lucky I had a horse outside me keeping me in, otherwise I probably would have run off the track. “
news, local-news, Goulburn Mulwaree Council, Upper Lachlan Shire Council, bushfire recovery assistance, Angus Taylor, Wendy Tuckerman, Bob Kirk, Bushfire Community Recovery and Resilience Fund
Two councils in the area will receive $100,000 each to help recover from last summer’s bushfires. Federal Hume MP announced the assistance under stream one of the joint federal and state Bushfire Community Recovery and Resilience Fund on Thursday. The money will go to Goulburn Mulwaree and Upper Lachlan Shire Councils to help “promote community well-being, social and future disaster resilience.” READ MORE: NSW bushfire community and resilience fund grants “(It) will allow Goulburn Mulwaree Council to develop procedures and acquire equipment to assist with the operation of an emergency evacuation centre and to provide local community grants to facilitate bushfire recovery and resilience activities,” Mr Taylor said in a statement. The Local Emergency Management Committee, comprising police, fire authorities, SES and other agencies, operates from the council chambers during fire, flood and natural disasters. ALSO READ: Moss Vale and Goulburn train station upgrades on track Mayor Bob Kirk said it ensured a coordinated response. “This funding is fantastic, and will be utilised to install technology and equipment that will make life much easier for the LEMC,” he said. Meantime, Upper Lachlan will use its $100,000 to improve communications across the Shire through enhanced transmission towers. Mr Taylor said the council would also be used to manage a local community grants program to facilitate bushfire recovery and resilience activities. ALSO READ: NSW mobile speed camera signs to go Upper Lachlan Shire Mayor John Stafford welcomed the boost. “Affordable access to fast download speeds and unlimited data is still part of the digital divide, and we’ve all become keenly aware of the need for digital connectivity this year,” he said. “Through better digital access, this funding will assist the provision of bushfire resilience and will improve liveability and the ability to conduct business in areas like Taralga.” Goulburn Wendy Tuckerman said the focus was on a locally-led recovery ensured fire-affected community had improved capacity and capability to respond to future disasters. ALSO READ: P-plater charged after allegedly clocking 199km/h “We are committed to supporting communities on the long road to recovery. We understand that locals know what they need best, so that’s why we are empowering local communities to make best use of this funding,” she said. The closing date for community applications for Stream 2 of the BCRRF has been be extended to provide adequate time for applications to be submitted. They will be accepted up until 12pm on December 11, 2020 and can be submitted at www.emergency.nsw.gov.au. We depend on subscription revenue to support our journalism. If you are able, please subscribe here. If you are already a subscriber, thank you for your support.
LOOMING: Communities like Taralga will benefit from bushfire recovery funding. The Green Wattle Creek fire raged near the town last summer and affected the economy. Photo: Rosey Stronach.
Two councils in the area will receive $100,000 each to help recover from last summer’s bushfires.
Federal Hume MP announced the assistance under stream one of the joint federal and state Bushfire Community Recovery and Resilience Fund on Thursday.
The money will go to Goulburn Mulwaree and Upper Lachlan Shire Councils to help “promote community well-being, social and future disaster resilience.”
“(It) will allow Goulburn Mulwaree Council to develop procedures and acquire equipment to assist with the operation of an emergency evacuation centre and to provide local community grants to facilitate bushfire recovery and resilience activities,” Mr Taylor said in a statement.
The Local Emergency Management Committee, comprising police, fire authorities, SES and other agencies, operates from the council chambers during fire, flood and natural disasters.
Mayor Bob Kirk said it ensured a coordinated response.
“This funding is fantastic, and will be utilised to install technology and equipment that will make life much easier for the LEMC,” he said.
Meantime, Upper Lachlan will use its $100,000 to improve communications across the Shire through enhanced transmission towers.
Mr Taylor said the council would also be used to manage a local community grants program to facilitate bushfire recovery and resilience activities.
Upper Lachlan Shire Mayor John Stafford welcomed the boost.
“Affordable access to fast download speeds and unlimited data is still part of the digital divide, and we’ve all become keenly aware of the need for digital connectivity this year,” he said.
“Through better digital access, this funding will assist the provision of bushfire resilience and will improve liveability and the ability to conduct business in areas like Taralga.”
Goulburn Wendy Tuckerman said the focus was on a locally-led recovery ensured fire-affected community had improved capacity and capability to respond to future disasters.
“We are committed to supporting communities on the long road to recovery. We understand that locals know what they need best, so that’s why we are empowering local communities to make best use of this funding,” she said.
The closing date for community applications for Stream 2 of the BCRRF has been be extended to provide adequate time for applications to be submitted.
We depend on subscription revenue to support our journalism. If you are able, please subscribe here. If you are already a subscriber, thank you for your support.
The Bulldogs have shown interest in Collingwood’s Adam Treloar; he did a medical with the yesterday and results were expected today. Those results will determine whether the Dogs pursue talks with Collingwood for the player who is contracted for five more years with the Magpies on about $900,000 a year.
As previously reported by The Age, it is not inconceivable, but it is unlikely, the Bulldogs would trade for Treloar and still hold onto Dunkley.
Collingwood’s Jaidyn Stephenson has met with North Melbourne as he considers his future.
Essendon’s Orazio Fantasia wants a move to Port Adelaide and the clubs are in talks.
“We’ve got until tomorrow night to get things done, I think that we’re a chance to get at least one of those deals done over the next 48 hours,” Power football boss Chris Davies said on Trade Radio earlier today, referencing discussions over Fantasia and Aliir. The Aliir deal has since been completed.
“… If we get to a point with one of those guys where we’re ready to do the deal, we’ll get that done and we’ll have to work with what we’ve got left to do the second one.”
He said they’d made offer to the Bombers that they thought was fair.
“We’re not going to walk away from Orazio … he’s told us he wants to come to Port Adelaide, we’ve got a responsibility to try and get that deal done, that’s the sort of club we are … but at the same time there’s a limit and we’re probably at that limit now, to be honest.”
We’re also waiting for news on deals for Jack Higgins, who wants a move from Richmond to St Kilda. Jake Niall reports that the Saints’ offer of a future second-round pick has not yet been accepted by the Tigers.
And Jackson Hately and Jye Caldwell, who want moves from GWS to Adelaide and Essendon respectively, are still waiting to learn their futures, as is Ben Brown, who wants to get to Melbourne.
With just over 24 hours left of trade period, there’s plenty to still get done.
Essendon now have picks six, seven and eight in the national draft, their strongest hand in years. The Bombers though are still negotiating other deals and will likely trade one or more of those picks.
The deal also means Essendon have been able to hang on to their future second-round draft pick (they do not presently have a second-round pick in this year’s draft).
Essendon had been firm that Saad deserved pick eight alone while Carlton believed that was too much and required something else back in the exchange. Carlton had pushed to hand over pick eight and a future third-round pick to Essendon for Saad and Essendon’s future second-round pick – a pick slide next year for Essendon.
But that future second-round pick was too valuable to Essendon because of the other deals they are trying to negotiate in this year’s trade period.
The Wallabies have claimed a 24-22 win over the All Blacks in a face saving victory at Suncorp Stadium.
But while it was an epic comeback from the 43-5 loss in last week’s Test which decided the Bledisloe Cup for an 18th year, a controversial first half delivered the talking points from the game.
Watch every match of the 2020 Bledisloe Cup & Tri Nations Live & On-Demand on Kayo. New to Kayo? Get your 14-day free trial & start streaming instantly
‘TOUGH’ RED CARD
In the 22nd minute the All Blacks’ Ofa Tu’ungafasi become the fifth All Blacks player of all-time shown a red card in a call that has divided the rugby community.
Social media was quick to react to the 22nd minute incident where the Wallabies’ Tom Wright dummied a kick from inside the 22 and began to step around All Blacks players.
That was until he came to Tu’ungafasi, who flattened the winger in what looked like a strong shot.
But on replay, it became clear his shoulder contacted Wright’s jaw.
RED card stings All Blacks!
1:04
“OK, so based on those factors, direct contact to the chin, there’s no mitigating factors, so it is going to be a red card against black three. Everyone agree?” referee Nic Berry said to the TMO before showing Tu’ungafasi the red card.
The decision was consistent with the World Cup in Japan but it has been a controversial ruling since the event.
Tu’ungafasi joins Cyril Brownlee in 1925, Colin Meads in 1967, Sonny Bill Williams in 2017 and Scott Barrett in 2019 as the only All Blacks to be red carded.
Social media exploded with comments with many believing it was a tough call but the right one under the rules.
Former Wallaby turned media personality Peter FitzSimons tweeted: “Very tough red card for All Black prop, yes? No evil intent on his part?”
Incredibly, the All Blacks were next to score through a penalty goal to make it 8-all.
‘RUINING THE GAME, RUINING THE SPECTACLE’
But it soon became duelling red cards when Wallabies debutant Lachlan Swinton was given his marching orders for a very similar incident in the 34th minute.
Swinton hit Sam Whitelock with a big hit, flattening the big New Zealander but it was quickly under review.
It was exactly the same penalty. You might not believe either is worth a red card but if the first one is a send off, then that one had to be too. #bledisloecup
Swinton was also the fifth Wallaby to be given a red card, joining David Codey in 1987, Drew Mitchell in 2010, Tevita Kuridrani in 2013 and Sekope Kepu in 2017.
Wallabies legend Matthew Burke said he believed both were worthy of red cards.
“It is red, absolutely. I thought it could have been a yellow because of the mitigating circumstances of Wright going down and then at the back end of it there is another one there and look at it, it is a heavy shot and just a missed shot and they spoke about that beforehand, about controlling that aggression and we said it as well at the start there,” he said on Channel 10.
But on Fox Sports, fellow Wallaby greats Justin Harrison and Phil Kearns took aim at the rulings at halftime.
“We talk about the framework of the rule changes that safety is the intent, but both of these players who received direct shots to the chin weren’t directed to go to the HIA for assessment so lets talk about mitigating factors,” Harrison said.
“We know that players don’t go out with the intent to take people’s heads off, what they do go out with through is with the intent to hit people as hard as they can. When you are moving as fast as you can as hard as you can and you’ve got 125kg that commits to a target, it’s very difficult to change that framework of decision.
Kearns added: “There’s got to be a better way. For me, yellow card, put them on report and then go to the judiciary afterwards. Ruining the game, ruining the spectacle.”
Get all the latest rugby news, highlights and analysis delivered straight to your inbox with Fox Sports Sportmail. Sign up now!!!
FOUL PLAY AND CLUMSINESS
Australia were then down to 13 men when Marika Koroibete was yellow carded after the halftime siren for having his hands all over the ball after a warning from the referee.
The All Blacks also went down to 13 men in the second half when Scott Barrett saw a yellow card after reaching out of the ruck to knock the ball out of Nic White’s hands.
Post-match, Harrison said “you cannot be allowed to get away with foul play because of clumsiness”.
Kearns also reiterated his comments from the first half, admitting that the red cards were correct under current rules.
“But in my view, it takes a lot away from the game to have the red cards,” he said. “Perhaps a better option is yellow card first, put them on report and deal with the judiciary process later so you can maintain the integrity of the game. I think there’s very little doubt in both of them.”
Wallaby great Tim Horan also argued for a red card seeing a player sent off but able to be replaced after 10 minutes.
Wallabies scrap for brave win
2:18
‘THAT’S A JOKE’
Nine Test veteran Greg Martin added that while it might be part of the rules, passive fans would are left scratching their heads with some calls.
“That’s a joke,” he said. “If we’re here in Australia competing with rugby league, and that’s what we are, but getting run from someone sitting in an office in Dublin deciding that that’s a red card, that’s nonsense, we can’t win that fight.”
All Blacks coach Ian Foster didn’t want to be drawn into a discussion of the issue.
It is what it is right now,” he said. “I don’t think now is a great time to debate the accuracy of the decisions. We were probably more unhappy with some of the TMO decisions last week than this week. Both teams got dealt with the same cards dare I say it.”
The Wallabies have claimed a 24-22 win over the All Blacks in a face saving victory at Suncorp Stadium.
But while the epic comeback from the 43-5 loss in last week’s Test which decided the Bledisloe Cup for an 18th year, a controversial first half delivered the talking points from the game.
In the 22nd minute the All Blacks’ Ofa Tu‘ungafasi become the fifth All Blacks player of all-time shown a red card in a call that has divided the rugby community.
Social media was quick to react to the 22nd minute incident where the Wallabies‘ Tom Wright dummied a kick from inside the 22 and began to step around All Blacks players.
That was until he came to Tu‘ungafasi, who flattened the winger in what looked like a strong shot.
But on replay, it became clear his shoulder contract Wright’s jaw.
On Channel 10, the discussion was around whether it would be a yellow or a penalty, but referee Nic Berry saw it much more black and white.
“OK, so based on those factors, direct contact to the chin, there‘s no mitigating factors, so it is going to be a red card against black three. Everyone agree?” he said to the TMO before showing Tu‘ungafasi the red card.
The decision was consistent with the World Cup in Japan but it has been a controversial ruling since the event.
Tu’ungafasi joins Cyril Brownlee in 1925, Colin Meads in 1967, Sonny Bill Williams in 2017 and Scott Barrett in 2019 as the only All Blacks to be red carded.
Social media exploded with comments with many believing it was a tough call but the right one under the rules.
Former Wallaby turned media personality Peter FitzSimons tweeted: “Very tough red card for All Black prop, yes? No evil intent on his part?”
Incredibly, the All Blacks were next to score through a penalty goal to make it 8-all.
But it soon became duelling red cards when Wallabies debutant Lachlan Swinton was given his marching orders for a very similar incident in the 34th minute.
Swinton hit Sam Whitelock with a big hit, flattening the big New Zealander but it was quickly under review.
Swinton was also the fifth Wallaby to be given a red card, joining David Codey in 1987, Drew Mitchell in 2010, Tevita Kuridrani in 2013 and Sekope Kepu in 2017.
Wallabies legend Matthew Burke said he believed both were worthy of red cards.
“It is red, absolutely. I thought it could have been a yellow because of the mitigating circumstances of Wright going down and then at the back end of it there is another one there and look at it, it is a heavy shot and just a missed shot and they spoke about that beforehand, about controlling that aggression and we said it as well at the start there,” he said on Channel 10.
But on Fox Sports, fellow Wallaby greats Justin Harrison and Phil Kearns took aim at the rulings at halftime.
“We talk about the framework of the rule changes that safety is the intent, but both of these players who received direct shots to the chin weren‘t directed to go to the HIA for assessment so lets talk about mitigating factors,” Harrison said.
“We know that players don‘t go out with the intent to take people’s heads off, what they do go out with through is with the intent to hit people as hard as they can. When you are moving as fast as you can as hard as you can and you’ve got 125kg that commits to a target, it’s very difficult to change that framework of decision.
Kearns added: “There‘s got to be a better way. For me, yellow card, put them on report and then go to the judiciary afterwards. Ruining the game, ruining the spectacle.”
Australia were then down to 13 men when Marika Koroibete was yellow carded after the halftime siren for having his hands all over the ball after a warning from the referee.
The All Blacks also went down to 13 men in the second half when Scott Barrett saw a yellow card after reaching out of the ruck to knock the ball out of Nic White‘s hands.
Post-match, Harrison said “you cannot be allowed to get away with foul play because of clumsiness”.
Kearns also reiterated his comments from the first half, admitting that the red cards were correct under current rules.
“But in my view, it takes a lot away from the game to have the red cards,” he said. “Perhaps a better option is yellow card first, put them on report and deal with the judiciary process later so you can maintain the integrity of the game. I think there’s very little doubt in both of them.”
Wallaby great Tim Horan also argued for a red card seeing a player sent off but able to be replaced after 10 minutes.
Nine Test veteran Greg Martin added that while it might be part of the rules, passive fans would are left scratching their heads with some calls.
“That’s a joke,” he said. “If we’re here in Australia competing with rugby league, and that’s what we are, but getting run from someone sitting in an office in Dublin deciding that that’s a red card, that’s nonsense, we can’t win that fight.”
All Blacks coach Ian Foster didn’t want to be drawn into a discussion of the issue.
It is what it is right now,” he said. “I don’t think now is a great time to debate the accuracy of the decisions. We were probably more unhappy with some of the TMO decisions last week than this week. Both teams got dealt with the same cards dare I say it.”