How fishing rights became a major stumbling block in U.K.-EU trade negotiations

© 2020 Fortune Media IP Limited. All Rights Reserved. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy | CA Notice at Collection and Privacy Notice | Do Not Sell My Info | Ad Choices 
FORTUNE is a trademark of Fortune Media IP Limited, registered in the U.S. and other countries. FORTUNE may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. Offers may be subject to change without notice.
Quotes delayed at least 15 minutes. Market data provided by Interactive Data. ETF and Mutual Fund data provided by Morningstar, Inc. Dow Jones Terms & Conditions:
S&P Index data is the property of Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc. and its licensors. All rights reserved. Terms & Conditions. Powered and implemented by Interactive Data Managed Solutions.

Source link

Brexit: Latest round of UK-EU talks come to an end

Image copyright
Reuters / EPA

Image caption

EU chief negotiator Michel Barnier met his UK counterpart David Frost this week

The UK and EU are to give updates on efforts to agree a post-Brexit deal following the latest round of talks.

While both sides have previously said a deal is possible, differences remain on issues including fishing rights and post-Brexit competition.

BBC Europe editor Katya Adler says a breakthrough is not expected this week.

The EU has said it would like to agree a deal by October so it can be approved by the European Parliament before the post-Brexit transition period expires.

The transition period ends on 31 December and, if a deal has not been secured by then, the UK would have to trade with the EU on WTO (World Trade Organization) terms.

This means most UK goods would be subject to tariffs until a free trade deal was ready to be brought in.

The UK has said it will not extend talks if an agreement cannot be reached by the December deadline.

EU chief negotiator Michel Barnier met his UK counterpart David Frost on Tuesday evening for dinner, and the pair are expected to have breakfast on Friday morning.

The two sides discussed transport, police co-operation, fishing rights and rules on investment.

The Financial Times reported that Brussels had rejected UK demands to allow British truckers wide-ranging access to the EU.

During the last set of talks in July, Mr Barnier said a deal looked “at this point unlikely” because of the UK’s position on fishing rights and post-Brexit competition rules, known as “level playing field” provisions.

And Mr Frost acknowledged “considerable gaps” remained in these areas, but added that the EU had shown a “pragmatic approach” over UK demands to limit the role of the European Court of Justice after the transition period ended.

He said he still believed a deal could still be reached in September, but the government must “face the possibility” one would not be struck.

Compromises on both sides are inevitable if a deal is to be struck, but don’t expect breakthroughs this week.

For now, much of Europe is still on holiday or dealing with the coronavirus crisis. Boris Johnson is also busy dealing with the fallout from the exams U-turn.

The EU wants a deal, but the keenness for an agreement – even a thin one – doesn’t mean they will settle for a deal at any price.

France is jumpy that Michel Barnier may be so keen to be seen to get a deal done with UK this autumn that he “could be tempted to give away too much”.

Meanwhile, German Chancellor Angela Merkel repeats over and over that the EU won’t agree to anything it believes would damage its single market.

The EU believes Mr Johnson needs to show he can reach a deal, especially after controversy surrounding the government’s initial handling of Covid-19.

But the politics of compromise shouldn’t be underestimated. Compromise can be found – but if it comes it is likely to be last-minute, around October time.

The EU thinks a deal is still more likely than no deal. But only just.

Source link

Post-Brexit talks: A chink of light at the end of the UK-EU trade tunnel?

Several rounds of talks on future trade and relations between the UK and the EU have taken place since the British departure from the bloc last January, with few significant signs of progress.

Even though negotiations have intensified over the summer, a breakthrough in the battle to reach a deal has remained elusive.

Although large differences remain on fundamental issues such as competition and fishing rights, both the UK and EU have shown willingness to compromise in some areas — leading to hope that a deal can be struck.

The standstill post-Brexit transition period which keeps most arrangements from the UK’s EU membership in place expires at the end of 2020.

This will bring major changes regardless of whether agreement on future trading and other relations is reached. But failure to strike a deal would magnify the challenges for business and the economy at a time when both sides are fully occupied fighting a war against the coronavirus pandemic.

The deadline in practice is the autumn to allow time for the ratification process by EU member states, a process that risks being longer and more complicated than it was for the Brexit divorce deal on the UK’s exit terms.

Convergence on the shape of a deal?

The EU’s chief negotiator Michel Barnier has been more upbeat in talking up the prospects for an agreement. He has reportedly told member state envoys that the UK has scaled down its ambitions and is seeking a “low-quality, low-profile agreement”.

The EU wants an overall, wide-ranging agreement in one comprehensive treaty, whereas the UK has been seeking a simpler free trade deal and separate agreement on other matters.

But after the fifth round of talks which took place in London, Barnier’s UK counterpart David Frost said in a statement that his side had “heard the EU’s concerns about a complex Switzerland-style set of agreements” and was “ready to consider simpler structures”, subject to agreement on dispute settlement and governance.

Barnier is also said to have repeated to envoys his belief, as stated in his assessment of the latest talks, that Boris Johnson’s government “want to find an agreement with the EU”.

No referee role for the ECJ?

David Frost said in his latest report that “the EU has listened to the UK on some of the issues most important to us, notably on the role of the (European) Court of Justice (ECJ).

The British side has consistently ruled out any jurisdiction for the ECJ over the UK’s laws, or in the prime minister’s words “any supranational control in any area”.

Brussels has previously said that if EU law needed to be interpreted, an arbitration panel should refer cases to the ECJ and follow its rulings.

The EU’s negotiator acknowledged in his latest assessment that “no role for the European Court of Justice in the UK” was the first of Johnson’s three red lines.

“We have tried to understand how these three red lines can be squared with our commitment to a comprehensive new partnership,” Michel Barnier said. “We made progress towards the objective of a comprehensive and single institutional framework, which must include robust enforcement mechanisms,” he added.

Progress on security cooperation

Future cooperation on policing and judicial matters was also singled out by Barnier as an area where “some progress” had been made after “good discussions”, although “divergences remain”.

Frost also said that both sides had “continued to deepen our understanding of each other’s constraints on law enforcement”.

Again, the EU’s scope for flexibility on the ECJ’s future role is thought to have helped bridge gaps.

Deadlock over level playing field and state aid

Despite the progress listed above, sticking points remain in crucial areas fundamental to any deal.

Ensuring fair competition — the so-called “level playing field” as enshrined in the divorce agreement’s Political Declaration” — is one of two such areas where Barnier says “no progress” has been made.

The EU negotiator accused the UK of refusing to commit to maintaining high standards axnd avoiding undercutting the EU in important areas such as climate, environment, labour or social law.

“On State aid… we have made no progress at all,” Barnier said, suggesting the UK wanted to use its future regulatory autonomy to “distort competition with us”.

Not for the first time, he said the UK had failed to provide “visibility” on its future regime to control domestic subsidies.

Fish fight continues as small industry punches big

Both sides agree that they are in a rut over fisheries, an industry of relatively small economic size but which is punching above its weight in terms of importance in the post-Brexit talks.

Barnier describes as “simply unacceptable” the UK demand for “near total exclusion of EU fishing vessels from UK waters”. The EU fully recognises the UK’s desire to be an independent coastal state, he adds, but “common stocks need to be managed jointly”.

For his part, Frost gives little indication the UK is ready to give ground on fishing, or over competition.

“We have always been clear that our principles in these areas are not simple negotiating positions but expressions of the reality that we will be a fully independent country at the end of the transition period,” he wrote after the last talks.

Canada dream

The UK’s chief negotiator says his side will continue to strive for a “Canada-style” free trade deal allowing for wide divergence from EU rules, something Brussels negotiators and EU governments have always rejected, especially given Britain’s economic clout and geographical proximity to the continent.

Other areas in need of agreement include financial services, mutual recognition of qualifications, data sharing and further details concerning trade.

Informal talks continue in the week of July 27 ahead of the next formal round of negotiations from August 17.

Source link